Investigating the Effective Components of Organizational Health of Iranian Extension System

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Department of Agricultural Extension and Education, Faculty of Economics and Agricultural Development, College of Agriculture and Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj-Iran

2 Department of Agricultural Extension & Education, Faculty of Economics & Agricultural Development, College of Agriculture & Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran

3 Department of Agricultural Extension and Education, Faculty of Economics & Agricultural Development, College of Agriculture & Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran

4 Department of Agricultural Extension and Education, Faculty of Economics and Agricultural Development, College of Agriculture and Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran

Abstract

Human resources are infrastructure of an effective agricultural extension system. What adds it, the importance of human resources for agricultural extension is the proper transformation of farmers and agricultural workers and the peasants, which is carried out by trained and experienced work force. For the purpose of respond to existing need, Iranian Agricultural Extension System must also prepare itself for effective management of future developments. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate the factors that influence the process of improving human resource management. One of the most important factor of this context is the organizational health of employees. The aim of this study was to identify the factors influencing the organizational health of the Iranian Agricultural Extension System, which was carried out using a qualitative approach. The survey population included faculty members of management at prestigious universities and managers of extension at the level of the Ministry of Agricultural Jihad, (deputy of extension) and the provinces. In the sampling method, the theoretical sampling method was emphasizes and the samples were selected to contribute to the creation of theory. In this study, 28 semi-structured interviews were conducted with experts related to the topic of research. Sampling was done by snowball sampling method in order to achieve theoretical saturation. To analyze the data, a continuous comparative analysis method was used and the extraction components in six categories include managerial competence, importance of human resources in healthy organization, inter-organizational factors, factors of workspace healthy, organizational constructive behaviors and organizational health impact, while interpretation of each component and constituent concept, recommendation and suggestions are presented.

Keywords


Extended Abstract

Objective

In the present era, organizations are no longer focus on their mass production, financial reserves and human resources Instead, the development of organizations depends on their intellectual capital (Movahedi & et al, 2018). Undoubtedly, human resources play a crucial role in achieving fundamental organizational goals (Karimi & Shahdousti, 2019). This issue is of particular importance in the agricultural extension system because the organization's behavior towards its audience is more sensitive and important. They can only progress and sustain their activities in extensional goals and agricultural development by preserving their true credibility and respect within the agricultural community. Considering that the agricultural system is considered a pioneer in achieving development goals of the millennium, the agricultural promotion system can assist farmers in connecting with various technical, non-technical, and market services (Kord & Piramoon, 2016). Review of studies has shown that the concept of organizational health initially emerged within academic environments, at the level of schools and universities educational environments. Only a few studies have examined it within commercial, industrial, and service environments. Furthermore, even its tools are often designed in educational environments and their use in organizational environments requires adjustment and modification. Therefore, the present research aims to explain the effective components of organizational health in the management structure of agricultural extension in Iran, using a qualitative approach.

Methods

In grounded theory, instead of starting the study with a preconceived theory, the researcher begins with a specific field of study, allowing the theory to emerge from the data. Theory derived from data is more likely to reflect reality compared to theory based solely on the accumulation of concepts from experience or contemplation (Strauss & Corbin, 1994). The duration of each interview ranged from 40 to 70 minutes. Immediately after recording, the content was transcribed word by word onto paper and then analyzed using the Strauss and Corbin method. The selection of key expert individuals, data quality, saturation of categories and emerging theory, and reaching theoretical saturation were the main criteria for determining the number of interviews. After reading the text of each interview and understanding it, an appropriate code was assigned to the desired phrase or paragraph. All interviews were coded using this method. In fact, the data coding process was carried out in three stages: open coding, axial coding, and selective coding.

Results

Out of 28 interviews (excluding overlaps), 225 codes were obtained, which remained 70 themes by considering overlap and integrating them for more accurate coding and facilitating the research process. Through continuous comparative analysis, the determination of whether each event in the data belongs to a category that is more prevalent or should be placed in a new category was systematically conducted. The initial categories were compared and reviewed multiple times, resulting in the merging of some categories or the emergence of new ones, ultimately summarized into 23 sub-categories. The raw data of the present research interview after coding and categorizing in the form of concepts, themes and categories led to the extraction of a central theme and the main phenomenon of the research. Through this category, researchers were able to link all the subcategories and categories and discover the central process of the research. The extracted components were categorized into six main categories and twenty-three subcategories, including managerial competence (desired organizational evaluation system, employee empowerment, managerial stability, comprehensive leadership, appropriate managerial strategies), the importance of human resources in  healthy organization (central theme), inter- organizational factors (optimal extensional system, positive organizational culture, internal trust, promotion of anti-corruption efforts), factors of workspace healthy (appropriate structure, organizational health precursors, financial resource equity), organizational constructive behaviors (effective and efficient communication, organizational participation, dynamic work environment, ethical management), and organizational health impact (organizational agility, improvement of human resource management, reduction of organizational indifference, organizational effectiveness).

Discussion

Extensional managers play a crucial role in organizations due to the influence they have on the behavior of subordinates and related individuals. This influence will affect the implementation of the organization's mission, employee behavior, and the type of interaction with other organizations and the agricultural community. Therefore, it is necessary for managers to pay attention to the appointment of deserving individuals to positions of importance and delegate responsibilities to them in a manner that they can fulfill them to the best of their abilities. Nowadays, the identification and implementation of a meritocracy system in administrative structures has become one of the tasks of organizations The conditions governing organizations require that according to the meritocracy logic of each person to be employed in accordance with the required expertise and training in the appropriate place. An appropriate organizational culture, accompanied by effective management, leads to outcomes such as improved performance and organizational functioning, increased job satisfaction, enhanced employee commitment, encouragement of innovation, and promotion of organizational social responsibility.

Corruption in administrative systems causes serious damage to development and progress, and in developing countries, its importance and the need for its control and prevention are evident to all. Corruption hinders healthy competition and contributes to increased poverty and social injustice. Combating administrative corruption at all levels of the agricultural extension body is necessary to prevent the exacerbation of damages in the future. On the other hand, an empowering structure includes rules and regulations that serve as a guide for problem-solving, thereby improving the problem-solving process. This structure refers to supportive rules and regulations that organizational leaders use to exercise their authority in managing organizational transformations, providing a necessary foundation for organizational leadership in complex internal and environmental situations. A capable structure empowers the organization to achieve organizational health and promotes flexible rules and procedures, viewing problems as learning opportunities, accepting value differences, encouraging initiative and innovation, fostering trust, facilitating problem-solving processes, enhancing collaboration, supporting employees, fostering participation, participatory decision-making, trust, honesty, credibility, unity, and creating a sense of power and influence among employees in the agricultural extension system in four dimensions: recognition, focus, process, and context. Promoting positive values in the organization motivates employees to contribute more to the organization and discourages organizational misconduct and cognitive deviances. In other words, spirituality in the workplace is a framework of organizational values that indicates the existence of a culture that increasingly transcends work processes and improves their understanding of communication with others­­­­­­.

Ahmadi,F &Habibitabar,Z.(2011). Survey relationship between organizational justice and the organizational health in public organizations in Iran. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research Business.3 (20)484-496.
Alman, D. (2010). Organizational health: improving organizational. Performance and employee wellbeing. Available at: http://www.proventivesolutions.com.au/organizational
Apipalakula,Ch., Kummoonb,D.(2017). The Effects of Organizational Climate to Conflict Management amongst Organizational Health Personnel. Seventh International Conference on Intercultural Education “Education, Health and ICT for a Transcultural World”, EDUHEM 2016, 15-17 June 2016, Almeria, Spain. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 237, 1216-1222
Arokiasamya, A.A., Abdullahb,A.K., Ahmad,M.Z., Ismailba,Sh.A.(2016). Transformational Leadership of School Principals And Organizational Health Of Primary School Teachers In Malaysia, 5th International Conference On Leadership, Technology, Innovation And Business Management. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 229, 151-157
Bahramian,A & Saeidian,N.(2013). The Relationship between Organizational Health, Teachers’ Organizational Commitment and their Perception of Elementary Schools Principals at Region 2, Esfahan in the -Academic Year 2012-2013.European online journal of natural and social science, 2(3), 2388-2396.(In Persian‌)
Cameron, K. S., & Quinn, R. E. (2011). Diagnosing and changing organizational culture: Based on the competing values framework (3rd Ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
Danaeefard,H., Davoodian,Z., & Ahmadi,H.(2016). Understanding the personnel strategies for the destruction of managers in government agencies, Evolution of change management letter,8(15).1-15.
Demir, M.(2011). Effects of organizational justice,trust and commitment on employees deviant behavior.Anatolia,22(2), 204-221.
Feli, S., Pezeshkirad,GH.R., Sadighi, H., Shahbazi, A.,& Ghoreyshiabhari, S.J.(2013).Iranian of agricultural extension system,current status and future.PhD dissertatin, Tarbiat Modaress University, Iran.(In Persian‌)
Fisher,A., & Zahrandika,A.(2009). Intergenerational Differences and their relation to recruitment and retention in a rapidly changing public safety workplace: Applying a 12-factor, 4-tier Modrl of organizational health, presentation American society of public administration applying an organizational health model annual conference, Miami,FL
Ghahramani,M., Abolghasemi,M., Arefi,M., & Khatami,M(2012).Assessing the organizational health of shahid Beheshti university, Journal of Job and Organizational Counseling, 10,13-30.(In Persian‌)
Gholami,S., Safari Keykala,M., Tir,M., Darzi Ramandi,F., Karimi,M., & Rajaee,R.(2015). Investigation the relationship between organizational climate and organizational citizenship behavior among staff in hospital, International Journal of Public Heath, Pharmacy and Pharmacology1 (1), 14-22. (In Persian‌)
Gholamzadeh, D., & Tahvildarkhazaneh, A. (2013). Relationship between leadership styles, organizational health and abuse. (Case study: raliway of the Islamic Republic of Iran), Journal of Public Management, 16,157-174. (In Persian‌)
Gholifar,E., Moradikafraj,M., & Rezvanfar,A.(2016).Effective organizational variables on improving the interactive status of Iranian agricultural faculties within the framework of organizational health, Iranian Journal of Agricultural Economic and Development Research,46(1),1,185-195.(In Persian‌)
Hajkhazimeh, M., Mirkamali, S.M., &Vaezi, M. (2015). Examination of the relationship between professional ethics of teachers and organizational health in government boys’ primary school in Tehran. Master of science thesis, university of Tehran, Iran.(In- farsi)
Hamdan Lafta, A., Man, N.B., Salih,J.M., Samah,B.A. Nawi, N., & Yousof, R.(2016). A need for investigation organization climate and its impact on the performance. European journal of business and management, 8(3). pp: 136-142.
Hari, A. P., Nair,D.K & Subramaniam S.R.(2015). Instrument development for organizational Health.Asian Social Science; 11(12); 200-214.
Hejazifar,H., Rezghi,H., & Hashemnia,Sh.(2017).Relationship of professional ethics and organizational discipline with employees administrative health, ,(Payam Noor Universities of Alborz Province). Journal of Future Studies Management, 28(108), 16-31. (In- farsi)
Iljinsa,j., Sarkanec,V.S.(2015). Impact of Organizational Culture on Organizational Climate during the Process of Change. 20th International Scientific Conference Economics and Management - 2015 (ICEM-2015). Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences 213,944-950
Irfaner, Ercetin, S.S. (2008). Organizational cleaner catfish. World Applied Sciences Journal, 3(4): 369-648
Janjirapon P, Viroj J. (2014). The impact of perceived organizational health and employee health on organizational citizenship behavior via the mediating role of work happiness of university lectures, Journal of International Management Studies, 14(1), 41-48
Kant,R.(2017). Organizational health of secondary school teachers in relation to their adjustment, Journal of Education Science and Psychology.3 (45).63-72
Karimi,S & Shahdousti,M.(2019). Studying The mediating role of organizational commitment in the relationships among social capital, job motivation and job Performance in Agriculture Jihad organization of Hamedan Province, Iranian Journal of Agricultural Economic and Development Research,49(2),4,703-717.(In Persian‌)
Kayzouri,A.H., Mohammadi Hosseini,S.A & Hosseinpoor,O.(2017).The role of Transformational Leadership in Organizational health in schools: Testing the Mediator Role OF Organizational Justice, Journal of school administration,5(2),80-101.(In Persian‌)
Khammarnia,M., Baghbanian,A., Mohammadi,R.,& Safari,H.(2013). The relationship between organizational health and performance indicators of Iran university hospitals. J Pak Med Assoc.63 (8).1021-1026.
Kord, A., & Piramoon, A.(2016). The necessities and requirements of the modern system of agricultural extension. sixth national congress of agricultural extension and education and natural resources.Shiraz: Shiraz university.(In- farsi)
Meng,F., Zhang,J., & Huang,Z.(2014). Perceived organizational health as a mediator for job expectation( A Multidimensional Integrated Model). Public Personal Management. 43(3). 355-370.
Meyandari,K.,Abedi Jafari,H., Najari,R., & Mahdipour,R.(2014).Providing a composite model for the design and explanation of a healthy organization.case study: ministry of cooperation,work and social welfare. journal of studies of organizational behavior,1,2.47-74.(In Persian‌)
Moradikafraj, M., Rezvanfar,A., & Gholifar,A.(2013). Organizational health of faculties of agriculture, journal of Management Research of Agricultural Education,25,3-15.(In Persian‌)
Movahedi,R., Samian,M., & Mohammadimehr,S.(2018). The effect of intellectual capital on the innovative behavior of agriculture Jihad workers of Kermanshah Provin, , Iranian Journal of Agricultural Economic and Development Research,48(2),1,123-136.(In Persian‌)
Nanda,B.U., & Narayan,S.B.(2010). Organizational Health, Stress & Commitment during global financial crisis. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations: 112-125.
Omoyemiju,M.A., & Adediwura,A.A.(2011). A study of teachers perception of schools organizational health in Osun State. World Journal of Education,1(1),165.
Pemberton,J.M.(2013). A search for core value: toward model code of ethics for information professionals, Journal of Information Ethics,9(1),26-54.
Poudineh,A., Yazdanian,H., & Rakhshani,M.(2015).Evaluation of organizational health and identification and ranking of its component(case study:agricultural jahad organizationof Sistan & Baluchestan province),Fourth Conference of Modern Management Sciences.Golestan:Gorgan. .(In- farsi)
Rajabani,N., Gholipour,A., & Ghaffari,M. (2014). Relationship of institutionalization of ethics relationship quality, job satisfaction and organizational commitment, Management Research of organizational Resources,4(2),15-32.(In Persian‌)
Ramdass, M., Lewis, T.(2012). Towards a model for research on the effects of school organizational health factors on primary school performance in Trinidad & Tobago. International Journal of Educational Development 32,482–492
Rashidian, M., Fayyazi, M., & Amin,F.(2014). Examining the effect of organizational health on job attitudes in alborz industrial group.Master of science thesis,University of Tehran, Iran.(In Persian‌)
Sang, M.C.(2011). Assessing Organizational Effectiveness in Human Service Organizations, Journal of Social Service Research,6(4),35-47
Sevi, E.(2010). Effects of organizational citizenship behavior on group performance, Journal of Modeling in Management, 5(1), 25-37.
Sheehan,M & Griffiths,J.(2011). Understanding the context of workplace health management as it relates to workplace bullying, International Journal of Workplace Health Management,4(1),5-12.
Sheibani,S (2013).The Effect of Management Style on Organizational Health in terms of Organizational Climate: A Case Study in Toranj GazCompanyE. European online journal of natural and social science. 2(3), 2944-2955. .(In- farsi)
Sivapragasam, P., Raya, P (2013). The healthy organization construct: A review and research agenda.Indian Journal of Occupational and environmental medicine,89, 3(17).
Stanford, N (2012). Organizational health: an integrated approach to bulding optimum performance. Kogam page publisher.
Suwanyuha, K., Rinthaisong, I.(2018). Structural equation modeling of organizational health in the marine fisheries management section under the fisheries management bureau. Kasetsart .Journal of Social Sciences, 39, 387-392
Torkzadeh,J., Salimi,Gh., & Sangi,F.(2016).Organizational apathy in the light of organizational structure development.Research management in Iran, 20(3),53-82.(In Persian‌)
Trong Tuan,L.(2013). Underneath organizational health: knowledge based sectoral employees.SCMS journal of Indian management:October –December.
Xenidis, Y., & Theocharous,K(2014). Organizational health: definition and assessment Creative Construction Conference. procedia engineering, 85, 562-570
Yen,C.H., & Teng,H.Y.(2013). The effect of centralization on organizational citizenship behavior and deviant workplace behavior in the hospitality industry. Tourism Management,36,401-410.I
Yuceler,A., Doganalp, B.,& Didem Kaya,D.(2013). The Relation Between Organizational Health and Organizational Commitment, Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 4(10),781-788.
Zahed-Babelana,A., Moenikiab, M.(2010). A study of simple and multiple relations between organizational health and faculty trust in female high schools. Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2,1532–1536.(In Persian‌)